Viw Magazine

The Times Real Estate

.

  • Written by Adrian Barnett, Professor of Statistics; President of the Statistical Society of Australia, Queensland University of Technology
Better opinions polls are more expensive because pollsters need to spend more effort getting a representative and honest sample of voters. Shutterstock

In 2012, US statistician Nate Silver correctly predicted the results of all 50 states in the US presidential election with 100% accuracy.

Compare this with the shock result of the 2016 Trump election, and now the 2019 Australian election, when nearly all Australian opinion polls incorrectly predicted that Bill Shorten’s Labor Party would defeat Scott Morrison’s Coalition on a two-party preferred basis.

How did the pollsters get it so wrong? More importantly, how can we ensure we get a more accurate result next time?


Read more: State of the states: Queensland and Tasmania win it for the Coalition


What opinion polls must do

A good opinion poll must do two difficult things:

  1. it must find a large and representative sample of Australian voters
  2. it must get those voters to honestly divulge who they will vote for.

If both of these things happen, statistical theory gives us confidence that the poll will be reliable.

To add to the difficulty, we don’t just need good opinion polls we need excellent opinion polls, because even a small error could mean predicting the wrong winner.

For example, if a government ministry wanted to know what percentage of people had done volunteer work in the last year, it probably wouldn’t matter for their purposes if they commissioned two polls which gave estimates of 48% and 52%. But this variation is unacceptable for electoral opinion polls, which need a small margin of error to accurately predict the winner.

How to get a representative sample

A good representative sample will be the whole Australian voting population, but in microcosm. If there are 16 million eligible voters, then a representative sample of 1,600 would mean that each sampled voter represents 10,000 people just like them.

Using relatively small samples is a cheap way to estimate the bigger picture of the election, without resorting to expensive surveys like the Australian same-sex marriage survey.

With a large and representative sample, statistical theory tells us that we will get close to the real result with a narrow margin of error. But the opinion polls in this election consistently predicted the wrong winner, meaning there was something wrong with the samples.


Read more: Coalition wins election but Abbott loses Warringah, plus how the polls got it so wrong


The problem of disruptive technology

Opinion polls are usually implemented by pollsters calling landlines, sometimes calling mobile phones, robo-dialling and internet surveys.

In the recent past when almost every Australian had a landline phone, it was far easier to get a representative sample of voters by randomly calling numbers or randomly sampling from the White Pages. The randomness is key, because it destroys bias by giving every eligible voter the same chance of being surveyed. This in turn avoids favouring particular groups.

Modern methods of communication have spoiled the representativeness of landlines – 36% of Australian adults now use a mobile only. And because older Australians are more likely to keep their landline, this biases any sample that uses landlines alone.

Far more Australians have a mobile phone than a landline – so why not use these instead? One reason is that some people have two mobiles – business and personal – so the poll would over-represent working Australians. And with fewer older people having mobiles, this approach would also over-represent younger Australians.

Even if we had a perfectly representative sample of phone numbers, we can expect a large number of people not to answer or hang up, which creates another bias because the poll then over-represents people with more time and those who are more politically engaged.

How to get honest answers

Opinion polls have been wrong before. Two examples are the 1992 and 2015 elections in the UK, where the polls wrongly predicted a good result for Labour. The post-mortem of these failings came up with the theory of the “Shy Tory factor”, where people were too embarrassed to admit to pollsters that they were voting for the Tories (the Conservative right-wing party).

Plenty of Australians are not embarrassed to tell anyone who they will vote for, but even the proportion of shy voters is small, then they could still derail the accuracy of the poll.

A number of Australian voters have admitted to giving fake answers to telephone polls because they were annoyed by the call. Even a small percent of annoyed people could ruin an otherwise well-designed opinion poll.

Another theory – put forward by Australian Nobel Laureate Brian Schmidt – is that the pollsters listened to each other more than they did the public. This is known as “herding”, where poll results that seemed to far from the norm were shepherded towards a groupthink.

An analysis of the numbers does show a striking lack of variability in the many recent polls.

How to get better polls

Better opinions polls are more expensive because pollsters need to spend more effort getting a representative and honest sample of voters. Some of the quick and easy polls that are currently used are primarily aimed at generating news stories, with accuracy as a secondary goal.

Poll accuracy could be increased by paying people to participate, and paying them more if, as a group, they get the result right. This is an untested idea, but it could create a strong incentive for people share their true intentions.

The same argument could also improve the pollsters’ strategies. That is, create financial rewards for getting things right, or penalties for getting them wrong. However, with shrinking budgets at news outlets to finance polling, there is no reason to believe that this problem is going to fix itself.


Read more: Going up. Monday showed what the market thinks of Morrison


Polling is a difficult job

An opinion poll targets the shifting opinions of an ever-changing population. Voters are often difficult to reach or recalcitrant. Yet much of the population is likely unhappy with the polls. They may never pay heed to polls again, or refuse to participate in them, which will ironically make the pollster’s job even harder.

Election opinion polls are like penalty shoot-outs at a World Cup final: there’s huge pressure to get it right and we remember the big misses most of all. But come the next World Cup we’re back watching the penalties, because nobody has come up with a better system to assess the national mood.

Adrian Barnett receives funding from The National Health and Medical Research Council.

Scott Sisson is Professor, Future Fellow and Head of Statistics at UNSW. He is a past-President of the Statistical Society of Australia and a Deputy Director of the Australian Centre of Excellence in Mathematical and Statistical Frontiers. He is a member of the Methodology Advisory Committee of the Australian Bureau of Statistics.

Authors: Adrian Barnett, Professor of Statistics; President of the Statistical Society of Australia, Queensland University of Technology

Read more http://theconversation.com/heres-how-to-make-opinion-polls-more-representative-and-honest-117405

How to Optimize API Calls for Faster Page Load Speeds in Headless CMS

A headless CMS allows companies to disseminate structured content across many front-end platforms and applications; however, because the s...

The Ultimate Guide to Jumping Castles and Playground Structures for Your Back Yard

Australia is renowned for its love of outdoor fun and family time. If you’re looking to create a safe and exciting space in your back yard...

Best Australian Cities for Electric Scooter Commuting

Source: NGMobility An increasing number of people are concerned about the environment. It’s driving interest in alternative technologies...

Navigating the World of Wisdom Teeth Extraction: A Comprehensive Guide

Ah, wisdom teeth. Those late-blooming molars that often arrive with a bang, or rather, a painful throb. If you're experiencing discomfort...

Why Melbourne’s Fast-Paced Lifestyle Makes Healthy Eating Hard

Melbourne is renowned for its vibrant culture, thriving arts scene, and bustling city life. However, this fast-paced environment often lea...

Beyond Comfort: The Vital Role of Air Conditioning Services in Commercial and Industrial Operations

While residential air conditioning is primarily about personal comfort, Air Conditioning Services in commercial and industrial environment...

Boat Life: Australia's New Love Affair with an American Dream

America's love affair with Pontoon Boats is about their geography; lots of canals, lakes, everglades, rivers and waterways that are magnet...

Why Perth Businesses Need to Master 'Near Me' Searches in 2025

In the bustling metropolitan landscape of Perth, business visibility has taken on an entirely new dimension. Where once local customers mi...

Sonya Saved $100k in a Year by Living the Van Life

Image from EnvatoA lot of people choose fly-in-fly-out (FIFO) work for the money. It’s hard work, with long hours working (and living) in ...

Smart Tips for Choosing a Top-Notch Rooftop Tent

Buying a rooftop tent is a big deal – they're not cheap, and you'll trust them to keep you safe and dry on your adventures. A good rooft...

Critical Criteria for Evaluating Enterprise-Grade SMS Delivery Platforms

The digital messaging ecosystem continues to evolve rapidly, yet SMS technology maintains significant relevance across numerous business a...

5 Essential Types of Air Compressors for Professional and DIY Applications

Air compressors serve as indispensable workhorses across numerous industries and workshops, converting power into potential energy stored ...

Sydney's Car Dealerships Increasing Security with Back to Base Alarms

Cars aren’t exactly cheap these days. Whether it’s a brand-new ute fresh off the lot or a luxury vehicle with all the gadgets, the las...

Realistic Strategies for Financial Independence

Developing financial independence calls for a planned strategy that strikes a balance between disciplined money management, smart investin...

How to Keep Your Strata Property’s Garden Well-Maintained

A well-maintained garden increases the beauty and value of a strata property. Dense and healthy landscapes are guaranteed by maintenance...

Work, Life, Kids? How a Nanny Can Be the Secret to a Happy, Balanced Home

It’s 7 AM, and the day is already chaotic. Parents are rushing to prepare breakfast, pack lunches, and answer early emails, all while ensu...

10 Common Mistakes People Make When Hiring Skip Bins (And How to Avoid Them)

Hiring a skip bin might seem straightforward, but many people make costly errors that lead to inefficiency, penalties, or environmental is...

Streamlining Operations with Integrated Fleet Management Technology

The modern business landscape demands efficiency at every level of operation, particularly for organizations that rely on vehicle fleets t...

Construction Insurance in Australia: What You Need and Why It Matters

The construction industry in Australia is fast-paced and dynamic, but it also comes with significant risks. From workplace accidents to pr...

Boost Your Brand with Promotional Bags: A Cost-Effective Marketing Strategy

Promotional bags are a powerful and cost-effective tool for businesses to market their brand, enhance visibility, and foster customer loya...